A letter to the Star from Thomas Atkin-Withers

 

Thomas Atkin-Withers Currently, the new elections bill (officially the Representation of the People Bill) is in Parliament. Now, credit where credit is due, the Government has proposed some important measures, a strengthened electoral commission, rules banning foreign donations and especially votes at 16.

Voting at 16 is something I would have loved to do as a teenager. I’m a youth charity trustee living in the Graves Park area. I know a lot of young people want to have their say on the issues that affect them.

Lack of affordable housing, record-high tuition fees, lack of youth facilities and services, SEND education, and urgent action to address the climate emergency. Votes at 16 includes people in the decision-making that affects them.

Labour could’ve brought proportional representation, ending MPs being elected without a clear majority, including a record 10 MPs that were elected with under 30% of the vote in 2024. This would prevent governments from having large majorities when only 33.7% of people voted for them. It could be allowed for Council and Mayoral elections too through the Single Transferable Vote, so councillors can’t be elected on 36.4% of the vote, as Graves Park’s councillor was in 2024, the lowest result for any elected councillor that year in Sheffield.

They could’ve abolished the Lords, an ever-growing house of cronyism, packed by prime ministers and their allies. No one should be able to sit in parliament because their ancestors did, or because they’re friends with the PM, or a Bishop.

They could’ve scrapped the bogus voter ID laws brought in by the Tories, which stopped 400,000 registered voters from having their say in the 2024 General Election, despite minimal evidence of any voter fraud in the UK.

Finally, they could’ve properly moved power out of Westminster, and devolved to the regions what is devolved to Wales, so money in Yorkshire can stay in Yorkshire to benefit people in Yorkshire, rather than being funnelled down to London. Devolution would allow us to improve healthcare, public transport, and housing, and bring down the cost of living, the priorities of people across Sheffield and Yorkshire more widely.

We need people across our country to actually be able to have a say and change things, rather than finding an ancient system in the way. That is the only way we can fix what is broken, for people across Graves Park and across our country.

Thomas Atkin-Withers, Candidate for Graves Park

A letter to the Sheffield Star

Cllr Bernard Little
Bernard Little

“I took a neighbour of mine to her polling station on election day. She was prevented from voting because she couldn’t find her passport. She has no driving licence. Her electronic pass with a photo as a worker in the NHS was deemed not permissible. I was able to vote because I had an older person’s travel pass.

In many places a student at a UK university or college who is eligible to vote, their student ID card despite it having a photo ID is invalid. A young person’s rail card is not acceptable.

The Electoral Commission reports that: “In the past 5 years, there is no evidence of large-scale electoral fraud. Of the 1,462 cases of alleged electoral fraud reported to police between 2019 and 2023, 10 led to convictions and the police issued 4 cautions.”  The Commission estimates that 8 million people are missing from the electoral roll which disproportionally affects private renters, young, Asian and black people. We need UK-wide automatic voter registration and the system we have should be repealed.

There is much bigger electoral fraud happening.

Lack of Proportional Representation is one.

No limit on the amount of money given to the bigger political parties to run their election machines is another.

The fact is our electoral system is unfair, runs in an ad-hoc way and is grossly unfair.

The UK is dangerously close to becoming like the repressive state of Belarus which like the UK uses a ‘First Past The Post’ voting system

We do not live in a democracy and this needs to change with great urgency.

Retired Cllr for Walkley and Upperthorpe.

Bernard Little